ONE! TWO! THREE! FOUR! HOW WE TRIED TO STOP THE WAR

This morning I attended a briefing by NYT Political Reporter Matt Bai; he was speaking on his new book The Argument: Billionaires, Bloggers, and the Battle to Remake Democratic Politics . It's a thoughtful, exciting look at American politics - very original. Although if you've read his stuff you know that's no surprise.

I was taking notes, so I headed the page with the date - and was stunned.  It was a memorable day, at least for me. 

Remember the Vietnam War?  Or at least all the stories you've been told about it?  Today, October 15th, is the 38th anniversary of one of the major demonstrations against that war -- after the chaos of 1968 and the election of Richard Nixon: the Vietnam Moratorium.

Described as the largest demonstration in US  history, it was quite a day. Astonishingly, Richard Nixon went to the Lincoln Memorial  -- in secret, in the middle of the night -- to talk to the demonstrators camping out on the grounds there.  Not astonishingly, hundreds were tear-gassed and rounded up -- many on the way to class at George Washington University,  and some, like my now-husband, on the way from his office to lunch.  This website from SMU quotes Steven Ambrose: "Tens of thousands of protesters marched around the White House on October 15th; across the country, in every major city, tens of  thousands attended antiwar rallies. It was, by far, the largest antiwar  protest in  US history.Altogether, millions were involved. There was little or no violence. Most disturbing to Nixon and his supporters,  the Moratorium brought out the middle class and the middle-aged in in very large numbers".

Yeah the middle class was there - and people even older than I am now.  It made a lot of noise and got a remarkable amount of attention.  Jerry Rubin and Abbie  Hoffman showed up, on bail from the Chicago Seven trial, and pulled off wigs to show that their hair had been shorn, like Sampson, by their Chicago jailers.   

Of course the war didn't end.  Years later an alleged Soviet spy told an interviewer that the demonstrations had been a dead give-away to the Russians that the US could not sustain the effort.  Who knows?  It was just one more huge event in many efforts to make the war go away.  I have just read that one of the leaders of SDS and one of my favorite thinkers, Todd Gitlin, in his new book, has urged today's activists to learn from what went wrong then.  They'd better.  For all we tried to do, we never got where we wanted to go and we left a legacy of polarization that still provides fodder for opponents in the culture wars.  It was a noble effort and probably helped demonstrate anti-war sentiment but now, in these times, we need a new way to do that.  It's intriguing that two highly-regarded thinkers like Bai and Gitlin are both looking at the future of Progressives at the same time -- just a year before the next presidential election. 

What do you think?  What should we have learned from the battles of the 60s -- and of the early years of this century?  What do we still have left to find out?
 

 

Comments

[Cynthia Samuels]

It's so weird that there are so many parallels - especially, in my view, in the poor execution mistakes, whatever one thinks of the mission. Sad too that we will, I fear, bear the scars in world opinion for years to come.

[Mrs. G.]

Wow. This is an amazing post...incredibly thoughtful. I plan to put the authors you mentioned on my library hold list. I was too young to have much of a memory of this war, but I will say that I think about the men and women who are dying or coming home injured physically and mentally EVERY DAY in this current war against "terrorism" and I feel such sadness. I hope this is the year, all troops are pulled out.